Daily Double: The Fifteen 1716: Four Jacobite rebels at Liverpool

1716: Lords Kenmure and Derwentwater but not Lord Nithsdale

February 24th, 2011 Headsman

This date in 1716 saw the beheading of two Jacobite lords, but it was more famous for the third who ducked the executioner in one of the Tower of London’s greatest escapes.

Lord Nithsdale, Escape from the Tower by Emily Mary Osborn(e)

Three were doomed to the block this date:

They were the fruit of Parliament’s impeachment of Jacobite leaders. Six of these fellows threw themselves upon the mercy of the Commons, and were rewarded with a death sentence by William Cowper. Only half managed to wrangle mercy from the crown.

On the eve of this date’s execution, Lord Nithsdale received a visitation of his wife, Winifred … who helped him swap clothes with one of her maids, in which garb he audaciously marched out the Tower gates in the train of his spouse.

The king whom Nithsdale had purposed to dethrone was a good sport about it. “It was the best thing a man in his condition could have done,” he declared.

The fugitives managed to cross the channel — that required another bit of dress-up, in the livery of the Venetian ambassador — and absconded to Rome. William Maxwell, Lord Nithsdale, outlived his appointment with the headsman by 28 years.

They are gone — who shall follow? — their ship’s on the brine,
And they sail unpursued to a far friendly shore,
Where love and content at their hearth may entwine,
And the warfare of kingdoms divide them no more.

“The Dream of Lord Nithsdale”

A letter detailing the escape from the pen of the intrepid Lady Nithsdale herself is well worth the read.

Her reputation as a romantic heroine (only enhanced by the romantic futility of the Jacobite struggle itself) has lent itself to all manner of literary expropriation, like this 19th century historical novel.

All very well for these two lovebirds. But the remaining 67% of the day’s scaffold carrion did not escape the Tower in women’s clothing, or men’s, and paid with their heads as scheduled.

Derwentwater went out with a peevish scaffold a ballad, “Lord Derwentwater” (or “Lord Allenwater”, or several similar variants), and another aptly titled “Derwentwater’s Farewell”.

His partner at the chop, Lord Kenmure,** also made the folk playlist in “O Kenmure’s On And Awa, Willie”, one of the ditties gathered by Robert Burns.

Having beheld all these various exemplars, Derwentwater’s brother and fellow Stuart supporter Charles Radclyffe decided to emulate them all.

Later that same year, Charles Radclyffe also made a successful prison break and got to the continent.

As a result, he was still around to participate in the 1745 Jacobite rising … and finally get executed for that.

(All part of God’s mystical plan for Radclyffe: look sharp and you’ll find him succeeding Isaac Newton as CEO of the legendary Holy Grail-keeping secret society Priory of Sion in Holy Blood, Holy Grail and its pulp novel knockoff The Da Vinci Code.)

* It’s impossible not to notice that this cross-dressing escape foreshadows that of Bonnie Prince Charlie when the Jacobite cause flamed out for good thirty years later.

** And like Lord Nithsdale, he was also blessed with a perspicacious wife — albeit one who wasn’t able to extricate him from the Tower.

On this day..

Entry Filed under: 18th Century,Beheaded,Capital Punishment,Death Penalty,England,Escapes,Execution,History,Martyrs,Nobility,Not Executed,Notably Survived By,Power,Scotland,Treason

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

10 thoughts on “1716: Lords Kenmure and Derwentwater but not Lord Nithsdale”

  1. yATmWfhxCe says:

    8917 326445This internet internet site is normally a walk-through its the data you wished about this and didn?t know who ought to. Glimpse here, and you will surely discover it. 642471

  2. Roland Ward says:

    hi – I have some letters of an old gentleman reporting on the events surrounding the 6 Jacobites on trial in 1716. He refers to Lord Nithsdale who escaped and also to a Lord Erwyn or Brwyn, however, I cannot see this peer named. Can you help to determine which one this may have been? Many thans

    1. Sue Latimer says:

      The six Jacobites tried in London in February 2016 were Derwentwater and Kenmure, who were executed, Nithsdale who escaped, and three who were reprieved: Widdrington, Carnwath and Nairn. Only Nairn would seem to fit the number of letters.

      Preston marked the anniversary of the 1715 battle last year and we are very interested in references to the battle and its aftermath. If you would be willing to share your letters, we would love to have copies to lodge at Lancashire Archives for researchers in future. We can be contacted via harris.museum@preston.gov.uk

  3. Derrick Jensen says:

    Do we know what happened to the maid?

    Oh, and thanks for a tremendous blog!

  4. Derrick Jensen says:

    Do we know what happened to the maid?

  5. Le Loup says:

    Good post on Lord Nithsdale, thank you.
    A Woodsrunner’s Diary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


February 2011
« Jan   Mar »



Execution Playing Cards

Exclusively available on this site: our one-of-a-kind custom playing card deck.

Every card features a historical execution from England, France, Germany, or Russia!