1930: Yang Kaihui, Mao Zedong’s wife 1724: Willem Mons, head grafter

2011: Oba Chandler

November 15th, 2012 Meaghan

(Thanks to Meaghan Good of the Charley Project for the guest post. -ed.)

A year ago today, Oba Chandler was executed by lethal injection in Florida for the brutal triple homicide of a Willshire, Ohio mother and her two teenage daughters.

Thirty-six-year-old Joan Mae “Jo” Rogers and her daughters Michelle, 17, and Christe, 14, were vacationing in Florida when they vanished on June 1, 1989. Three days later their bodies turned up in the Tampa Bay. All three were naked from the waist down and had their hands and feet bound, their mouths taped shut, and concrete blocks tied to their necks. Michelle had managed to free one arm before she drowned.

The victims (left to right): Joan, Michelle, and Christe Rogers.

The police initially suspected the girls’ uncle, John Rogers, even though he was in prison at the time.

Rogers had been incarcerated for rape; one of his victims was Michelle, and authorities theorized he had a third party kill her and her mother and sister. Eventually that gentleman was cleared, as was his brother Hal, husband and father of the victims.

The sexual abuse, which had gone on for years, had torn the family apart, and part of the reason for the Florida vacation was so that everyone could relax and get some distance from what had happened. Hal had wanted to join his wife and daughters on their trip, but he had to stay and look after the family’s dairy farm.

The murders and subsequent investigation were covered in heartbreaking detail in St. Petersburg Times reporter Thomas French‘s Pulitzer Prize-winning series here.

Characteristically, local gossip pursued Hal and John for years, particularly Hal. His neighbors in Ohio thought he didn’t appear traumatized enough,* noting that he never cried in public and that he continued to take care of his farm in the wake of the murders.

They didn’t care that the farm was Hal’s livelihood, that cows could not milk themselves. They didn’t care that there was no evidence that he’d left Ohio during the critical time period, and that the police had very quickly cleared Hal as a possible suspect in Jo, Michelle and Christe’s deaths. They didn’t know that he was too traumatized to sleep in his own home and spent months couch-surfing at friends’ houses. They didn’t know that he was devastated, that he’d tried to take his own life at one point so he could be with his family.

As Hal’s sister-in-law said, “There’s no protocol here. There’s no Murder 101 class. No Grief 101 that anybody thinks to give you.”

Stranger-on-stranger crimes are incredibly difficult to solve. It wasn’t until October 1989 that the police linked the Rogers family’s murders to the rape of a Canadian tourist that had happened in May, two weeks before the triple homicide. The rapist had lured the woman out onto a boat, threatened to kill her, and threatened to duct-tape her mouth if she didn’t stop screaming. After the rape he apologized to her, threw up over the side of the boat, took her to shore and let her go.

Police released a composite sketch of the woman’s attacker, whom they believed was the same man who killed the Rogerses. That got over 400 tips from the public, but none of them panned out.

Twice, the case appeared on the popular television show Unsolved Mysteries.

The authorities found some driving directions written on a brochure in Jo’s car which were not in her handwriting and which they thought were written by the murderer; they released samples to the public in the hopes that someone would recognize the writing.

Composite sketch of the suspect (top); Oba Chandler as he looked around the time of his 1992 arrest (bottom).

Finally they got a break: one of Chandler’s neighbors recognized the sketch of the rape suspect and turned his name over to the police. That same neighbor had hired Chandler to build out her porch, and she had a copy of the contract he’d written out for her. She turned the contract over to the authorities, and handwriting experts determined it was written by the same man who wrote the driving directions found in Jo’s car. Investigators also found Chandler’s palm print on the brochure.

In September 1992, convinced that they were on the right track, the police flew to Canada to interview the rape survivor from May 1989. She picked Chandler’s photo out of a line-up. With that, the authorities finally had enough evidence to make the arrest.

Chandler, an Ohio native like his victims, gave the impression of an ordinary, mild-mannered sort, but he was in fact a career criminal: he went by many alias names and had an arrest record dating back to when he was fourteen years old, for a wide range of offenses including car theft, robbery, kidnapping, receiving stolen property, possession of counterfeit money, and various sex crimes. By the time of his 1992 arrest he had racked up six felony convictions.

Chandler testified at the murder trial, against the advice of his attorney, and admitted he had met the three victims and given them directions. He could hardly deny that, given the handwriting and fingerprint evidence.

He did deny having ever seen them again after that, and he swore he’d never taken them out on his boat and never harmed them. He called the very idea “ludicrous.” In fact, he maintained his innocence until his death.

But the prosecution eviscerated him during cross-examination. Chandler claimed that on the night of the murders he’d gotten stuck out in Tampa Bay when his boat’s fuel line sprung a leak and he ran out of gas. A boat mechanic employed by the Florida Marine Patrol examined the vessel and determined that this story was impossible: the boat had an anti-siphon valve that would have prevented a leak.

The Canadian rape victim was permitted to testify. She didn’t cry as she described what happened to her, but some of the jurors did. One of Chandler’s adult daughters (he had eight children by seven different women) also testified, saying her father had told her he’d raped a foreign tourist and also killed some women in Florida.

The judge who presided over the trial later said Chandler was “the vilest, most evil defendant I ever handled.” When the jury retired, they took an initial poll among themselves and discovered that all twelve believed he was guilty. For form’s sake, however, they waited an hour and a half before returning with their verdict.

There’s some speculation that Chandler was involved in other murders besides those of the Rogers family.

Linda Lois Little, a Daytona Beach woman, disappeared on his birthday in 1991 and was never found. One of Little’s sisters thinks saw him at her apartment complex a few days before Little disappeared. Chandler refused to answer law enforcement’s questions about Little’s disappearance and his involvement has never been proved one way or the other.

During his seventeen years on death row, Chandler never had a single visitor, not even any of his own relatives. The execution, which went smoothly, was attended by Michelle and Christe’s cousin, as well as a reluctant Hal Rogers. He remarried more than a decade after his family’s murder and became a stepfather of four, but wasn’t able to have any more children.

When asked if he had any last words, Chandler simply answered, “No.” He did leave a written statement that simply said, “You are killing an innocent man today.”

No one believed him.

* “Didn’t display the right kind of grief in the right kind of way for the right amount of time” was also one of the raps on wrongly executed “arsonist” Cameron Todd Willingham.

On this day..

Entry Filed under: 21st Century,Capital Punishment,Common Criminals,Crime,Death Penalty,Execution,Florida,Guest Writers,Lethal Injection,Murder,Other Voices,Political Expedience,Rape,Ripped from the Headlines,USA

Tags: , , , , , , ,

7 thoughts on “2011: Oba Chandler”

  1. Melissa says:

    A justifiable execution is NOT murder. A policeman who kills a criminal is NOT a murderer. Killing in self defense is NOT murder. It is the State’s duty to see that justice is done. The State took over this duty in order to prevent family and relatives from taking the law into their own hands, it is NOT revenge either. The biblical injunction of “an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth” refers to proportionality in punishment; i.e., if someone takes the life of another for no justifiable reason, then he shall have his own life taken.

    1. Kevin Sullivan says:

      Very well said, and completely accurate. Even war is not murder, although acts of murder can and do happen in war.

      Also, while the King James Bible says “Thou shalt not kill” (confusing people), that was a mistake in translation. The accurate translation from the Hebrew is “Thou shalt do no murder”, and this is how the King James should have translated this scripture.

  2. Tom OMara says:

    I have always been opposed to capital punishment because it just seems to be a “lawful” way of committing pre-meditated murder…but after reading about Oba Chandler and the sheer sadistic savagery of his crime against the Rogers girls I am relieved to know was not allowed to live out his natural life…

    1. cpinva says:

      “I have always been opposed to capital punishment because it just seems to be a “lawful” way of committing pre-meditated murder…”

      and you would be correct. execution is considered “justifiable” homicide per the law. so yeah, it’s murder, but legally so. I too am opposed to capital punishment, as it leaves no room to correct mistakes, and it makes the state my agent in committing murder. it’s basically revenge, with the blessing of the state.

      there are, however, some crimes for which the only suitable punishment would seem to be capital. I personally claim no great wisdom in knowing where to draw that line, except for crimes against children.

  3. Meaghan says:

    Watched a TV program about this case tonight and thought to Google Chandler’s name even though he’s been dead for five years. Turns out he kidnapped, raped and strangled a woman named Ivelisse Berrios-Beguerisse in 1990. The murder went unsolved until 2014, when DNA from the crime scene turned out to be a match for Chandler.

    One article said the cops “believed Chandler was linked to other abductions and rapes dating as far back as 1963.” Gotta wonder if he committed other murders besides these four. If it turns out he had, I wouldn’t be in the least bit surprised.

  4. Meaghan says:

    On a personal note, the Rogers family came from the same part of Ohio where I’m from. I have a brother who was killed in a car accident, and after that my parents joined Compassionate Friends, a support group for people whose children have died. My dad met Hal Rogers at one of the Compassionate Friends meetings and told me about it at the time, what had happened to him. I was a little girl, seven or eight years old I think, and I remember being horrified. Wondering how a person could still be walking around and breathing and everything after their entire family had been murdered.

    Hal dropped out of Compassionate Friends before long. Apparently his tragedy was too much even for them, and he felt they couldn’t relate to him.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


November 2012
« Oct   Dec »



Execution Playing Cards

Exclusively available on this site: our one-of-a-kind custom playing card deck.

Every card features a historical execution from England, France, Germany, or Russia!