Feast Day of Saint Agnes 1348: The Duke of Durazzo, all in the family

1855: Emmanuel Barthelemy, duelist

January 22nd, 2014 Headsman

The winner of England’s last fatal duel was hanged at Newgate on this date in 1855 … but not for the duel.

Both participants in that duel, Emmanuel Bart(h)elemy and Frederic Cournet, were French emigres* who had commanded Parisian barricades during the 1848 revolution.

On its surface the duel was one of those trivial affairs of honor: Barthelemy heard that Cournet (otherwise unknown to him) had repeated some defamatory rumors about Barthelemy already abroad in France, and challenged Cournet on that basis; Cournet at first dissociated himself from any such smears, but upon better consideration thought he considered Barthelemy’s notice a little on the ultimatum side and took exception to that.

The consequent set-to was delayed some time by negotiations over every element of its ceremony. When at last it was arranged, it unfolded thus:**

it should commence with pistols, the combatants, being 40 paces apart, advancing 10 paces before firing if they chose, and having two shots each, miss-fires not counting; that the choice of position, the choice of pistols, and the signal for firing should be determined by tossing up; that if the pistols proved ineffectual swords should be resorted to to terminate the affair.

Cournet won the toss and got to choose his position and take the first shot. Barthelemy had to stand stock-still as Cournet

advanced his 10 paces and fired, but though on 14 similar occasions he had never failed to hit his opponent this time he missed. Barthelemy then told him that he had his life in his hands, but would surrender his right to fire if Cournet would agree to terminate the duel with swords. [Barthelemy had wanted swords to be the dueling weapon in the first place -ed.] Cournet declined to do so, saying that he would stand his adversary’s fire and take his second shot. Barthelemy then levelled his pistol, but … it snapped. He put a fresh cap on and it snapped a second time,† and it was then agreed that he should use Cournet’s pistol, which was loaded and handed to him. Before discharging it, however, he again offered ineffectually to terminate the contest with swords. He then fired, and with fatal precision.

Barthelemy himself and all four of the seconds involved (both Barthelemy’s and Cournet’s) were arraigned in this case, but the jury returned only a manslaughter verdict. Barthelemy served a few months; he would have to exercise fatal precision once again to find a different route to the scaffold.

In his non-duelling life, Barthelemy was a mechanical engineer, and it was in this capacity that a soda-water manufacturer named George Moore employed him to repair his machinery at 73 Warren Street, just off Fitzroy Square.

Late the night of Friday, December 8, Barthelemy showed up with a veiled woman at the place and asked for Moore. Minutes later, the servant-girl saw all three emerge struggling violently together from their private meeting. As she raced to the door to scream for help she saw the Frenchman raise a pistol and fire …

“Murder!”

Her screams started attracting the neighbors as Barthelemy burst past her, but an iron gate in front of the house obstructed him. Before more people could assemble he fled back into the house and locked it shut behind him.

Moore’s neighbor, a former East India Company man named Charles Collard, thought quickly to his own grief. Collard raced around the back side of the house where a garden opened onto another street, and arrived just in time to catch Barthelemy vaulting over the garden wall. Collard pounced on him, and in the ensuing melee Barthelemy shot him, too.

This was all too late for Barthelemy, for the delay had brought an onrushing of neighbors and passersby who quickly subdued the gunman. Somehow — nobody quite knew how — his companion was nowhere to be found. She had vanished from the house leaving only her veil, and as she had surely not escaped by the front gate it was thought that she must have found some way to slip out the back casually amid the commotion and made a nonchalant escape. She was never seen again.

Moore was found quite dead in his home: he’d been shot through the head, and the marks on his body indicated that the fatal wound had been preceded by some whacks with a cane. Collard lingered on many hours in agony — long enough for his captured murderer to be brought before him and Collard to deliver a signed j’accuse identifying Barthelemy as the villain.

Barthelemy must have had a way with jurors because even in convicting him for murder on this occasion, the panel still recommended mercy. There seems to have been some thought that the mysterious dispute in the house might have been a spontaneous affair qualifying as manslaughter, while the murder of Collard might have passed (since Collard grabbed Barthelemy) as self-defense. The crown unsurprisingly did not share this exceptionally generous view of a man who had already been in the dock for homicide in the past and declined to extend mercy.

Barthelemy disdained the religious entreaties of his captors, scandalizing the right-thinking with bon mots like “it is no use to pray to God, as God will not break the rope.” Indeed, He did not.

* It was perhaps fitting that Frenchmen, a people with an abiding enthusiasm for the duel, who transacted this milestone encounter. En garde!

** Per the London Times of Oct. 28, 1852, summarizing evidence presented in court.

† Upon post-duel examination it emerged that Barthelemy’s pistol had failed to discharge because of a bit of linen rag stuck in the breach. This eyebrow-raising fact gave rise to the suspicion of foul play, though on whose part and to what end is less distinct. Both guys ended up with a shot at one another with the exact same pistol. Cournet just missed his.

On this day..

Entry Filed under: 19th Century,Capital Punishment,Common Criminals,Crime,Death Penalty,England,Execution,Hanged,History,Murder,Public Executions,Revolutionaries

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

36 thoughts on “1855: Emmanuel Barthelemy, duelist”

  1. lilidi says:

    Der ist nicht nur das Thema und das sind französische bulldogge preis

  2. lauraty23 says:

    Great Content deer antlers are good for decoration.and for you your dogs and puppies great content to share.have you hear of sugar gliders and hedgehogs before? Follow my content for more

    französischen bulldogge

  3. Saam Linkin says:

    FÜHRERSCHEIN ONLINE KAUFEN

    Thanks For The Content..Really Good
    More of Similar Content,Check The Link

  4. 23lauraliam says:

    nice work taxidermie great job

    kjhgfddfghjkjl

  5. lauratylin says:

    great seeing such amazing and outstanding quanto costa comprare la patente content guys

  6. Si vous rencontrez des problèmes pour obtenir un permis de conduire, vous pouvez nous contacter directement par e-mail (dokumenteonline1@gmail.com) dans toutes les régions de l’UE, en Allemagne, au Portugal, en France, en Espagne, en Suède, aux Pays-Bas, en Belgique, en Suisse, Estonie, en Italie et L’Autriche. Nous vous donnons tous les conseils pour obtenir votre permis de conduire enregistré sans aucun problème. Aucun examen passé. https://www.achetez-permisdeconduire.com/

  7. gdtfdr544 says:

    Achetez un permis de conduire réel et enregistré sur notre site Web sans passer d’examens ni passer le test pratique. tout ce dont nous avons besoin, ce sont vos données et elles seront enregistrées dans le système dans les huit prochains jours. Le permis de conduire doit subir la même procédure d’enregistrement que ceux délivrés dans les auto-écoles,
    https://www.permisdeconduirefacile.com/

  8. dfgrr454t54 says:

    rijbewijs kopen in nederland of belgie en binnen maximaal acht dagen bij je laten bezorgen
    https://echtrijbewijskopen.com/

  9. dfgtrt444 says:

    Kaufen Sie einen registrierten deutschen Führerschein und erhalten Sie ihn innerhalb weniger Tage nach Hause geliefert. Der von uns angebotene Führerschein ist vollständig und rechtsgültig registriert und lässt somit keine Zweifel an der Echtheit aufkommen.
    https://www.deutscherfuhrerschein-b.com/

  10. dferr34r4 says:

    deutschen Führerschein und erhalten Sie ihn innerhalb weniger Tage nach Hause geliefert. Der von uns angebotene Führerschein ist vollständig und rechtsgültig registriert und lässt somit keine Zweifel an der Echtheit aufkommen.
    https://fuhrerschenkaufen.com/

  11. dvgr3433 says:

    Comprare un diploma registrato e legale dall’italia senza sostenere gli esami. contattaci per ulteriori informazioni su questo sito
    https://comprarediploma.com/

  12. dferre43 says:

    carteira de motorista real e registrada em nosso website sem fazer nenhum exame ou fazer o teste prático. tudo o que precisamos são seus dados e eles seriam registrados no sistema nos próximos oito dias. A carteira de habilitação deve passar pelo mesmo procedimento de registro que as emitidas nas autoescolas,
    https://imt-cartadeconducao.com/

  13. fgr34443 says:

    Acquista la patente di guida reale e registrata dal nostro sito Web senza scrivere esami o sostenere il test pratico. tutto ciò di cui abbiamo bisogno sono i tuoi dati e saranno registrati nel sistema entro i prossimi otto giorni. La patente di guida deve seguire la stessa procedura di registrazione di quelle rilasciate nelle autoscuole,
    https://patentevera.com/

  14. Blaq says:

    imi contenuti ragazzi, mi hanno davvero aiutato molto dopo tanto tempo, continuate a fare un buon lavoro
    https://deutschenfuhrerscheinkaufen.com

  15. Rotimi says:

    teúdo, pessoal, realmente me ajudou muito depois de um longo tempo, continue com o bom trabalho b et rigtigt og registreret kørekort på vores hjemmeside uden at gå til eksamen eller tage den praktiske prøve. alt, hvad vi behøver, er dine data, og de vil blive logget ind i systemet inden for de næste otte dage. Kørekort skal gennemgå samme registrerings
    https://rijbewijskopenb.com

  16. bryunessdaw says:

    timo conteúdo, pessoal, realmente me ajudou muito depois de um longo tempo, continue com o bom trabalho
    https://comprarcartadeconducao.com

  17. Blaq says:

    t og registreret kørekort på vores hjemmeside uden at gå til eksamen eller tage den praktiske prøve. alt, hvad vi behøver, er dine data, og de vil blive logget ind i systemet inden for de næste otte dage. Kørekort skal gennemgå samme registreringsprocedure som dem, der udstedes på køreskoler
    https://comprarlicenciadeconducir-b.com

  18. Ojo says:

    og registreret kørekort på vores hjemmeside uden at gå til eksamen eller tage den praktiske prøve. alt, hvad vi behøver, er dine data, og de vil blive logget ind i systemet inden for de næste otte dage. Kørekort skal gennemgå samme registreringsprocedure som dem, der udstedes på køreskoler.
    https://comprarepatentediguida.com

  19. 0x0 0x0 says:

    0x0 0x0 error is a security error that is commonly encountered when trying to access files or resources on your computer. The error typically occurs when the user tries to access a file that does not exist or when they try to access a resource that is not available. It is important to note that this error typically occurs when you are using Windows Explorer, Chrome, or Firefox.

  20. Thank you a lot for giving everyone a very remarkable opportunity to read articles and blog posts from this web site. It’s usually so pleasant plus packed with a lot of fun for me personally and my office fellow workers to visit the blog minimum thrice in a week to learn the newest guides you have. Of course, I’m so actually motivated for the incredible tips and hints served by you. Selected 3 areas in this post are rather the most effective we have all had.
    Comprar permise de conducir original

  21. 0x0 0x0 says:

    It’s normal to assume that if you’re reading this, you’re looking for a solution to the Error code “0x0 0x0”. Many questions may be in your mind, like, why do 0x0 0x0 errors occur? How to solve 0x0 0x0 error? How do i fix 0x0 0x0 error? If you face the same issue, you’ve come to the correct place because we’ll let you know everything there is to know about Error 0x0. The 0x0 error code is one of Windows users’ most common issues worldwide. So, if you think you’re dealing with this issue on your own, you’re mistaken.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Calendar

Archives

Categories

Execution Playing Cards

Exclusively available on this site: our one-of-a-kind custom playing card deck.

Every card features a historical execution from England, France, Germany, or Russia!