Qu’est-ce que c’est?
It was 20 years today that Ted Bundy, the signature sexual psychopath in a golden age of serial killers,* rode the lightning in Florida’s Starke Prison.
Executed Today is pleased to mark the occasion with a conversation with Louisville crime writer Kevin M. Sullivan, author of a forthcoming2009 book on Ted Bundy … and a man who knows how the world looks from inside Bundy’s ski mask.
Ted Bundy is obviously one of the most iconic, written-about serial killers in history. Why a book about Ted Bundy? What’s the untold story that you set out to uncover?
The desire, or drive, if you will, to write an article about Ted Bundy and then create a 120,000 plus word book about the murders, was born out of my crossing paths with his infamous murder kit. Had Jerry Thompson [a key detective on the Bundy case -ed.] left Bundy’s stuff in Utah that May of 2005, well, it would have been an enjoyable meeting with the former detective, but I’m certain it would have all ended quietly there. Indeed, I doubt if I’d even considered writing an article for Snitch [a now-defunct crime magazine -ed.], much less a book about the killings. But it was having all that stuff in my hands, and in my home, and then being given one of the Glad bags from Ted’s VW that made it very real (or surreal) to me, and from this, a hunger to find out more about the crimes led me forward.

Ted Bundy’s gear, right where you want it — image courtesy of Kevin M. Sullivan. (Check the 1975 police photo for confirmation.)
Believe me, in a thousand years, I never would have expected such a thing to ever come my way. I can’t think of anything more odd or surreal.
ET: You mentioned that you think you’ve been able to answer some longstanding questions about Bundy’s career. Can you give us some hints? What don’t people know about Ted Bundy that they ought to know?
I must admit, when I first decided to write a book about the crimes, I wasn’t sure what I’d find, so the first thing I had to do was read every book ever written about Bundy, which took the better portion of three or four months.
From this I took a trip to Utah to again meet with Thompson and check out the sites pertaining to Bundy and the murders in that state. Next came the acquisition of case files from the various states and the tracking down of those detectives who participated in the hunt for the elusive killer.
Now, no one could have been more surprised than me to begin discovering what I was discovering about some of these murders. But as I kept hunting down the right people and the right documents, I was able to confirm these “finds” at every turn. And while I cannot reveal everything here, It’s all in the book in great detail. Indeed, you could say that my book is not a biography in the truest sense, but rather an in-depth look at Bundy and the murders from a vantage point that is quite unique. I wish I could delve further into these things now , but I must wait until it’s published.
The Bundy story has a magnetic villain and a host of victims … was there a hero? Was there a lesson?
The real heroes in this story are the detectives who worked day and night for years to bring Ted Bundy to justice. And if there’s a lesson to be learned from all of this, it is this: It doesn’t matter how handsome or articulate a person might be, or how nicely they smile at you, for behind it all, there could reside the most diabolical person you’ll ever meet! We need to remember this.
But how can you act on that lesson without living in a continual state of terror? Bundy strikes me as so far outside our normal experience, even the normal experience of criminality, that I’m inclined to wonder how much can be generalized from him.
Actually, (and I might say, thank God here!) people as “successful” as Ted Bundy don’t come our way very often. I mean, the guy was a rising star in the Republican Party in Washington, had influential friends, a law student, and certainly appeared to be going places in life. Some were even quite envious of his ascension in life. However, it was all a well-placed mask that he wore to cover his true feelings and intentions. On the outside he was perfect, but on the inside a monster. He just didn’t fit the mold we’re used to when we think of a terrible killer, does he?
Now, there are those among us — sociopaths — who can kill or do all manner of terrible things in life and maintain the nicest smile upon their faces, but again, just beneath the surface ticks the heart of a monster, or predator, or what ever you might want to call them. Having said that, I’m not a suspicious person by nature, and so I personally judge people by their outward appearance until shown otherwise. Still, it’s difficult (if not impossible) to see the “real” individual behind the person they present to us on a daily basis.
You worked with case detectives in researching your book. How did the Ted Bundy case affect the way law enforcement has subsequently investigated serial killers? If they had it to do over again, what’s the thing you think they’d have done differently?
They all agree that today, DNA would play a part of the investigation that wasn’t available then. However, in the early portion of the murders, Bundy made few if any mistakes, as he had done his homework so as to avoid detection. As such, even this wouldn’t be a panacea when it came to a very mobile killer like Bundy who understood the very real limitations sometimes surrounding homicide investigations.
I can’t help but ask about these detectives as human beings, too. Clearly they’re in a position to deal with the heart of darkness in the human soul day in and day out and still lead normal lives … is a Ted Bundy the kind of killer that haunts or scars investigators years later, or is this something most can set aside as all in a day’s work?
They are, first of all, very nice people. And you can’t be around them (either in person, or through numerous phone calls or emails) for very long before you understand how dedicated they are (or were) in their careers as police officers. They are honorable people, with a clear sense of duty, and without such people, we, as a society, would be in dire circumstances indeed.
Even before Bundy came along, these men were veteran investigators who had seen many bad things in life, so they carried a toughness which allowed them to deal with the situations they came up against in a professional manner. That said, I remember Jerry Thompson telling me how he looked at Ted one day and thought how much he reminded him of a monster, or a vampire of sorts. And my book contains a number of exchanges between the two men (including a chilling telephone call) which demonstrate why he felt this way
How about for you, as a writer — was there a frightening, creepy, traumatic moment in your research that really shook you? Was there an emotional toll for you?
Absolutely. But the degree of “shock”, if you will, depends (at least for me) on what I know as I first delve into each murder. In the Bundy cases I had a general knowledge of how Bundy killed, so there wasn’t a great deal that caught me by surprise, as it were. Even so, as a writer, you tend to get to know the victims very well through the case files, their family members or friends, and so on. Hence, I’ll continue to carry with me many of the details of their lives and deaths for the remainder of my life. And so, lasting changes are a part of what we do.
However, I did a story a few years back about a 16 year old girl who was horribly murdered here in Kentucky, and this case did cause me to wake up in the night in a cold sweat. Perhaps it was because I have a daughter that was, at the time, only a few years younger than this girl, and that some of what transpired did catch me off guard, so to speak, as I began uncovering just what had happened to this very nice kid.
Watch for Kevin M. Sullivan’s forthcoming The Bundy Murders: A Comprehensive History from McFarland in summer or fall of 2009.
* In fact, the term “serial killer” was coined in the 1970’s by FBI profiler Robert Ressler, as an improvement on the sometimes inaccurate category of “stranger killer”.
Additional Bundy resources from the enormous comment thread:
-
Video of Wildwood Inn, where Bundy abducted Caryn Campbell in 1975. (From Timmy)
Thread commenter Richard A. Duffus wrote a 2012 book about Ted Bundy, Ted Bundy: The Felon’s Hook (Excerpt | Image from the book)
Video interview of Kevin M. Sullivan (From Richard A. Duffus)
On this day..
- 1522: Didrik Slagheck
- 1887: Georgette and Sylvain Thomas, guillotine couples act
- 1981: Not Kim Dae-jung, South Korean president and Nobel laureate
- 1641: Not Manuel de Gerrit de Reus, chosen by lot, saved by hemp
- 1970: Three in Baghdad
- 1538: Anna Jansz, Anabaptist
- 1963: Lazhar Chraiti and nine other Tunisian conspirators
- 1846: Elizabeth Van Valkenburgh, in her rocking chair
- 1936: Allen Foster, who fought Joe Louis
- 1911: Shusui Kotoku and ten other anarchists
- Daily Double: The High Treason Incident
- 1938: Han Fuqu, Koumintang general
- 1992: Ricky Ray Rector, "a date which ought to live in infamy for the Democratic Party"
Abi, Richard, Fiz, and all: Yes, it is indeed sad about Lorraine.
An interesting story: Lorraine first approached me through the comment section on Amazon. I must say, she was at first very upset seeing her name and the personal details about herself contained in my book (personal details, such as dorm room number, etc). Anyway, her son discovered THE BUNDY MURDERS on the internet, and using a name search at Google Books, discovered the passage about her. So at first she was offended. But after I responded, and told her that I had obtained the info from the official reports from the campus investigator (giving her additional info from those reports, including the name of the investigator) she calmed right down (LOL!) and we became friends. We exchanged many e-mails, and yes, I did convince her to post at ET. So it was a good thing.
Also, it was exceedingly important to me that she was able to confirm two facets of the events of that evening that I suspected occurred (but couldn’t prove) when she ran into Kathy Parks just before Bundy abducted her. First, I knew from the record that Kathy mailed a letter to her boyfriend, Christy, McPhee, the night she disappeared (May 6th) as the letter bears a May 7th postmark. My thought was (and I mention this in the book) that she may have mailed it around this same time Lorraine had spoken to her. Lorraine confirmed to me that as they talked that night, Kathy held the letter in her hand and dropped it in a mail box about twenty feet away from them after they finished their conversation, and then Kathy walked across the narrow on-campus street to the cafeteria where Bundy came up to her. Also, I felt that Bundy might have been following Lorraine, as she had just come from the library, and then he decided to go after Kathy, as Lorraine was heading home. Well, Kathy told me that a man resembling Bundy kept bothering her in the library, and when she left the library with other students, he followed her but kept his distance. She then ran into Kathy and forgot about this guy. Well, there is no proof that it was Bundy, but I believe it most likely was, as he was a known hunter of women at libraries. So, in my mind, these two little suspicions I had were finally confirmed.
Lorraine was a very nice lady. She was also, like many of the family and friends of murder victims, emotionally scared from the event, and as such, we should remember they were victims too.
I am so sad to hear about Lorraine! She changed the whole tone of our discussion, and although I remember some people here were rude to her (not sure why!) she handled it so well and really gave a glimpse into what the atmosphere back then was like.
I wish her family stregth during this difficult time. I had no idea she was so poorly, and am even more grateful in that light, that she took the time to chat with us. Thank you Kevin for inviting her! And P.S, I hope that lovely bracelet is looked after by future generations.
I too am saddened by Lorraine’s death. Besides her contributions here, she was willing to speak with me offline and offered valuable insights from the perspective of the victims’ families.
Oh, Kevin that’s very sad indeed. I thought Lorraine was lovely. R.IP.
Diana– Bundy had an odd trait, in that he sometimes wanted the remains to be discovered. Not only the remains of the heads, but bodies were left by roadways. He had a reason for doing this, and I believe there was a part of him that took pride in his “work” and wanted it discovered. Besides the actual murders, and what diabolical pleasure he received from committing them, he enjoyed terrifying people and taunting the authorities.
The public finding remains is one way of doing that.
Shelley– Very often, the families and friends of those murdered will carry pain throughout their lives. And yes, it was special that Lorraine joined us here. I am saddened by her death.
Kevin,
Why would Bundy have wanted the heads to be discovered? During the Washington days, he was as meticulous as could be and tried to keep as much hidden from the public as possible. Since this would enable identification, In your opinion, WHY would he want the heads discovered?
Thanks for letting us know about Lorraine. I found it very ‘special’ (can’t find the right word) to hear her story and to see Kathy Parks as a person and not just a name/victim. I am having a hard time finding the right words but hopefully you know what I mean. I was also struck by how much Lorraine was still affected by what happened even after all these years.
To all who read this blog:
It is my sad duty to report that Lorraine Fargo, who so graciously answered questions about her life and friendship with Kathy Parks so many years ago, has passed away. I have just learned that she died in March. I was aware she had some medical issues, but I did not know they were so serious.
I’m very happy we, as a group, got to be friends with her, and that she felt comfortable sharing her life with us. She will be missed.
He dumped the heads so that there was a good chance they’d be discovered. There is no other explanation for it, as he himself admitted that everything which was buried has stayed hidden. He could have done the same thing with the heads.
I cover this in my book, LOL!
It is believed that he dumped all the heads on Taylor mountain at the same time, correct? WHY do you think he dumped the heads in a way that they could be found Instead of burying them with the bodies so that they likely WOULDNT be found?? What’s your take on why he did that?
Diana–
While Bundy had two dump sites in WA, the remains of some of those bodies may be in a third or fourth location. Also, if my memory serves me correctly, he had as many as four heads in his WA apartment.
Keep in mind, Bundy would occasionally change things, even while he operated in WA. He would do so for various reasons, probably depending on something that was of the spur of the moment.
I really enjoy this forum; having a place to discuss all this Bundy stuff with others who are equally as intrigued.
Now, some questions Kevin, Richard,
-Do you think Bundy had a specific dump site for the Washington victims? In other words, did he likely have 1 specific remote place he used to kill and dump their bodies before taking their heads?
-Ott, Naslund, and Hawkins bodies were found together, correct? Is there a speculated place where he killed those 3 victims nearby that body dump site?
-And WHY do you think he only took one of their heads and not all?
Bart– I show Custer as he was in life, the bad points with the good. He’s a very interesting person, but I would never hide the faults of any person I’m writing about, and play up only their good points. That would be a no, no, LOL!
Kevin,
How do you deal with moral assessment of your characters when writing on them? I don’t mean Bundy naturally. He is not difficult to asses in moral terms. But General Custer? He was controversial person for some historians. Do you just write just neutral account of his life or deeds or do you praise him or just opposite you blame him? I noticed that while studying and writing on a given person (not a criminal in my case) I develop kind of emotional attachment to my ‘ subject’. I am becoming more forgiving and I have tendency to present my subject in a better light, omitting things that might make picture my hero as not such a good person. I don’t think it is a good approach for genuine researcher. I should cover both wonders and sins lol!
Strike the “of” above. I’m so tired, LOL!
A tape or tapes exist, but I’m not sure of about a transcript.
Is there a transcript of Bundy’s final confession tape made by the warden? If so, it will settle the question about Oliverson.
Vidor, without question, Bundy was indeed hunting on the night of his arrest in Granger, Utah, and I cover this in my book. According to the police report, the passenger seat was out and lying in the back, and the murder kit was open, its contents spilling out. In other words, he was ready to go.
Bundy also made an interesting comparison between his Utah arrest and his arrest by Officer Lee in Pensacola, and how they (the detectives) did not understand the significance between the two arrests, but they would. .
Very much overstating the case to say that Sam Cowell was “almost certainly” Ted’s father. We don’t know and never will.
Denise Oliverson was on the list of victims that Ted confessed to by name; no idea why that case was later reopened as now they will never close it.
Reading George Dekle’s new book. Absurdly overpriced but a good read. Contains one surprising bit of info–apparently Ted told Norm Chapman that he was in fact hunting for victims both when he was arrested for the first time in Utah and the last time in Florida.
Thanks, Kevin.
I will never surrender lol!
Bart– Yes, write as you go along. But remember, it is never easy creating something out of nothing. Putting together hundreds of thousands little facts, and making it a book takes dedication, time, will-power, and a refusal to quit. This is why, for all the people who say they’re going to write a book, very few do. So just keep at it, and do not quit.
Thanks, Kevin
I was rather thinking about overload with kind of pre-writing preparations like reaching stuff unavailable on the internet, locating people to contact them, e-mailing them, traveling to places, spending hours at libraries. So far it was a big satisfaction to me to move forward with the project but recently I have said to myself: “I am temporarily fed up with this mess.” Maybe I should start writing now for a while even without the information I desire to have? Just to relax myself? And afterwards I will go back to ‘hunting and gathering’ even if it will mean re-writing and correcting some parts?
Bart– Any such work, true crime or otherwise, can at times feel overwhelming. For me it works like this: When I’m writing a book, there is within me an inner-drive to to the work. I become totally involved in the work, and mostly, I write and research during the day, and I enjoy my work immensely. But I am thinking about what I’m doing (or what needs to be done) all the time. None of this is ever overwhelming. However, if I begin writing again at night — say, from about 6 pm till 9 or 10, as I approach the end that evening, I’m dragging, and I feel that I can’t write even one more thing about the subject at hand. And it goes beyond the typing aspect of things. I just can’t stand thinking about it any longer, LOL!
As you know, I’m currently writing the Custer book. It’s a lot of fun to do this one, and I’m learning many things along the way. And while it doesn’t have any of the depressing aspects to it that sometimes accompany true crime work, the same thing often happens. It happened last night. Around 10 pm I said to myself: “If I have to endure just one more Indian attack, I don’t know what I’ll do!!!” LOL!
Hi, Kevin!
Another researcher workshop question from me!
Do you happen to experience a kind of overload with your subject when doing a research? And if yes, what do you do at that moment? Do you take a short break from your task, just to regenerate? Or maybe you still go forward with your project regardless of your inner feelings? Specially, the time factor sometimes is crucial and there is no time to take any leave because people open to speak to me can change their minds – for example. It is my first ‘serious’ project and I am scared that even the smallest vacation from what I try to do will make me discouraged and put me dangerously close to abandon my project. You, as a true crime writer, have special ‘right’ to feel overloaded with crime scenes, autopsy reports etc. But I am doing a project about an artist however the overload caught me and is not going away!
Take care
Bart
Hi Laura,
I don’t think it was me either that you meant to address! LOL 🙂 No harm done.
I am all for leaving them alone especially at this late date. I really feel for the loved ones of the victims AND Bundy’s family.
Apologies Shelly that should read – god it’s only 12pm here in Scotland and already I feel worn out!!! lol
Fiz – please read back my reply to you (where I mention you) I most certainly did not “put words into your mouth” nor is that something I would do that has offended me – you will in fact see I mention Shelly by name when I say they should not be contacted but in fact on reading back it was Abi who mentioned it (apologies Abi)
Laura, I never at any time suggested that Louise and her other family should be contacted. They too have a life sentence. I just said I found some of her attitude strange.
I am currently reading Robert Keppel’s book, Serial Violence, and it has crime scene photos in it that are pretty graphic. I understand the educational value of such pictures but I can’t help but think about the loved ones of these people.
How do we balance the their right to privacy against having to have this info ‘out there’ in court, for educational purposes in law enforcement, etc.?
I don’t know.
ETA if her father was indeed Ted’s father why would she “come clean” later in life again imagine dealing with something like that? Why would you also want the world to know and delve into something so difficult? What could be served by it? Bundy was what he was, I believe a combination of both nature and nurture – but plenty of people are adopted, raised in a one parent household, the product of incest etc and do not do what he did. His mother should be left alone as should the families and victims families, they should not be expected to talk to the press or anybody else nothing more can be gained and I am certain if Louise Bundy wrote ten books on his life and upbrining nothing more could be gained in respect of what he did other than he was wrong.
Fiz – maybe decisions were made? Perhaps she went back for him because she couldn’t not? Nobody knows so in my opinion to speculate on such a thing gets us nowhere, we do not know the hardship nor the situation and god only knows how a girl of her age felt having to leave her baby that had grown inside her all that time. Give birth and have to give up. I find it awful to try to think that she did what she did out of anything other than hardship, and we do not know any of the hardships this woman faced but whatever she went through she went back for her baby so perhaps she was forced into something and found the courage to go against it. As I said before a different time, a different era.
Shelley – why should she speak to the press or writers? This was her son, a monster, but a monster she gave birth too. Nobody will ever find out why he did what he did and I’m certain his family do not know either. Why should they clear anything up? I’m sure they did with the people that matter i.e.investigators but anything else only serves as a fuel for those fascinated with the case. As much as the family of Bundy’s victims suffered so too did his own family and I am with Kevin – keeping quiet does not mean they have anything to hide, perhaps they just had a hard time dealing with it themselves – if that was me I certainly wouldn’t cope and I would not be giving press pictures or inside scoops so to speak I guess they wanted to leave it where it was. I guess having our own interests them speaking out would only serve to give us some more information or another interesting angle but lets not forget their lives were torn apart by this too.
It’s a terrible situation for all involved, Shelley, that’s for sure.
Obviously, there are no winners here. It’s a terrible situation. I feel for Bundy’s family but mostly for the loved ones of the victims. Their bodies and personal lives, etc. become ‘public’ property…out of necessity but still…
I don’t know how those people survive it. I relate mostly to the parents. No wonder they say parents who lose children die earlier on average!
You would think that as a writer, and especially one who wrote an in-depth biography of Theodore Bundy, I would be offended that the Bundy’s won’t answer questions, but I’m not. I fully understand. And I do not believe things were necessarily seen by the family (clues), that would lead them to believe Ted was a killer. People can be moody, depressed, and act in various ways that speak of emotional upheaval. But I’m sure there were no signs which would cause them to think he was turning into a diabolical killer. Again, the mask.
The Bundy family are victims as well. Ted did what he did, and they have been changed forever by it. They have a right to be left alone.
I agree with Fiz, there is something totally unethical about the family’s determination to ignore pleas from journalists and writers, who could use them to dig into why or how Ted Bundy could have been identified or helped sooner. I think TB himself genuinely did not know! – but doubtless the facts and clues were all there. Although one must sympathise with the family and Louise especially, and they are of course all innocent, nevertheless even the speculation about TB’s heritage should have been conclusively cleared up. When her father died, she could have come clean – if indeed that rumour is true. I don’t suppose it is though, it sounds like the sort of thing ppl make up to try and convince themselves how much of an aberration that monster is – when the truth is far more chilling precisely because it is more prosaic. But as I said, all speculation.
Laura, I have no problem with Louise being of a different generation. I agree it was very difficult to have an -out-of-wedlock baby then, but surely some decisions about the baby should have been made while she was pregnant with him – such as was she going to keep him or put him forward for adoption? I also agree than no woman should have give birth to her father’s child, but I do draw the line at a child taking money and not paying it back. I would make my child re-pay or pay the person back myself. I wouldn’t laugh about it. She did. Also Ted had a juvenile record of petty crime and she had to know about that.
ETA: if Ted’s grandfather was, as has been speculated, his father can you imagine what that poor woman went through physically and emotionally. It does not bear thinking about.
Fiz,
About Louise, when you say about the loving mother but leaving him on his own for three months. While this is not condoned – as a young girl in an age where having children out of wedlock was not the norm nor accepted we do not know what kind of pressures she was facing to do such a thing. I read a book about children of a similar era born to young mothers shamed into giving them up – they would go stay with “Aunt” for a few months (away to give birth) then return a while later back to normal. It’s very sad and I do not think she can be judged for this.
As for the money thing, perhaps she just knew her son well in that he was a chancher and a fool and his money so to speak. For me these don’t tell me much. That she will not speak does not tell me much either, as Kevin said why would they? Regardless of what he did, she gave birth to him, raised him and he was still her son. Who knows maybe she just found it too painful, not only having her own sons death to live with but also what he put other families through and their pain too. I cannot begin to imagine how that would feel. My grandmother is of a similar era to Louise and also quite stern in her ways, closed ranks as far as family are concerned and somewhat cold but I just think she is a product of her generation.
There’s something not right about Louise Bundy. She’s painted as being Christian and a loving mother, but she left Ted for three months on his own after having him, her father was almost certainly Ted’s father, and laughed when Freda Rogers contacted her when Ted owed her a lot of money and told her she’d been a fool to lend it and she wouldn’t get it back. If it had been my child, I would have allowed them to dig at Crescent Lake if I was totally convinced my son was innocent.
“far” instead of “fer” and ‘Chances are” instead of “Chances”…
Abi-
The Bundy family will not speak with writers or anyone else about the case. They haven’t for years now, and as fer as Louise is concerned, the answer will always be no. Chances, the children will never speak about it, either. Why should they?
Yes the police didn’t exactly care too much about the victims’ families (gosh I shudder to think of poor Naslund mother especially) so why start now? The Ted Bundy case is still so legendary in US and indeed the world, that finding bones or solving cold cases would be a huge coup so I’m sure if there was a reasonable chance they would go ahead. The trouble is obviously these searches etc are very costly, so as Kevin says, they’re not about to go on a wild goose chase and hunt down every patch of land that might have once been connected to the Bundy family or anything like that.
I am wondering why no author has made it their mission to track down Louise Bundy before it’s too late – I mean at the very least the family have tons of photos which would make any book on TB a bestseller alone; and at best she might have been able to be coaxed to give up extra vital info. Has any author tried this route…? I know the family is innocent but I am a believer in nurture being key, so I always look straight to the mother haha just call me Freud.
There are families like the Kents and Cunninghams who sought their daughters’ remains while others like the Hawkins would not want them found. So if one were to go to a single location and find a some sort of mixed combination I would think they would all have to be recovered regardless how some of the families felt.
Yes, if it works for them, that’s all that matters.
And I would add that whatever works for them, we have to respect, having been there, done there kinda thing.
Hi Anna– I just saw your post 4036. The folks I’m talking about have their own reasons for wanting their daughter left where she remains today. I do not know their reasons, only their wishes; and I’m getting these second-hand, as they say.
See ya!
Yes. Hard to believe, isn’t it?
Very odd that out of the same state (Utah) comes Ancestry.com, they got rid of stuff regarding one of the most infamous serial killers!
Richard, I believe the GJ folks believed they’d cleared that case after Fisher told them the news. Somebody must have have a problem later with it, and the result is the open case. I’m really surprised they left it open. That is the case Fisher and Bundy were talking about, and that is the case he answered on tape. Too bad they didn’t close it.