James Stephens hanged in New York on this date in 1860, for poisoning his wife.
We’ve referenced passingly a number of 19th century hangings on then-trendy “upward-jerking” gallows — whose action is not to drop the offender down through a trap, but to drop a heavy weight which levers the offender up.
Thanks to the Feb. 4, 1860 edition of the New York Herald, we have a very detailed description of this macabre device.
Perhaps the reporter’s skepticism as to this machine’s humane efficacy is informed here by a bit of hindsight, for when it engaged to end the life of our Mr. Stephens,
Up went the culprit high into the air, not with a sudden violent jerk as usual, but slowly, as if by the strength of a man’s arms, instead of a powerful weight of some 300 pounds. It became evident immediately that something was wrong, and soon a rumor went round that the rope had been unwound instead of cut by the hangman. It appeared that the executioner, who was inexperienced, got frightened, and thus the barbarous manner of hanging the culprit was explained.
It was extraordinary that under these circumstances the unfortunate wretch, suspended between heaven and earth, did not exhibit indications of violent suffering. The moment the rope tightened around his neck, and he was elevated about half way up, a slight twitching of the fingers and kicking of the legs were perceptible. Then a few moments intervened without the slightest indication of suffering, except the hard breathing, which was fearful to listen to. After hanging two minutes in this way, another convulsive throe took place; the vessels in the neck seemed to be swelled almost to bursting, the fingers and wrists assumed a bluish hue, and the feet twitched once or twice spasmodically. Three minutes came, and with it a very feeble tremor showed itself in the whole body; but it lasted only a few seconds, when all further motion ceased, and life seemed to be completely extinct. The surgeons, Drs. Woodward, Simmons and Covell, viewed the body after a suspension of five minutes, and gave it as their opinion that animation was certainly gone; but the body was not lowered until fourteen minutes had expired. The surgeons then again examined the body, found no pulse, and the flesh icy cold. Considering the circumstances, the culprit died a remarkably easy death, which was owing, doubtless, to the feeble condition of his constitution. Had he been in good strength at the time of his execution there is no question but that he would have struggled in the most frightful agony for half an hour.
On this day..
- 1685: James Algie and John Park, Paisley Covenanters
- 1977: Marta Taboada and Gladys Porcel, Argentina revolutionaries
- 1903: Amelia Sach and Annie Walters, the Finchley baby farmers
- 2016: Brandon Astor Jones
- 1891: Michel Eyraud, bailiff-strangler
- 1814: Mariano Matamoros, Mexican revolutionary
- 1578: Blessed John Nelson, martyr
- 1537: "Silken Thomas" FitzGerald, Earl of Kildare
- 1945: Not Fabian von Schlabrendorff, saved by a bomb
- 1967: Ronald Ryan, the last hanged in Australia
- 1915: Veljko Cubrilovic, Danilo Ilic and Misko Jovanovic, Archduke Ferdinand's assassins
- 1998: Karla Faye Tucker, for an axe murder and a Republican presidency